Members of Lodge No. 461 meeting at Moy would have been drawn from the surrounding district. Meetings were generally held on the night of a full moon allowing for safe travel on horseback in an era of poor quality roads.
| NO. | MEMBER | NOTES |
| 1 | William NEWTON | admitted July 7 1768, made master July 7 1768 |
| 2 | Benjn. NEWTON | admitted July 7 1768, made warden 7 July 1768 |
| 3 | Alexr. ORR | admitted July 7 1768, made warden 7 July 1768 |
| 4 | Saml. GREENWOOD | admitted May 22 1769 |
| 5 | John DONNELL | admitted May 22 1769 |
| 6 | Jas. MCFARLIN | admitted May 22 1769 |
| 7 | Mat. GREER | admitted May 22 1769 |
| 8 | Thos. COOEY | admitted May 22 1769 |
| 9 | John CONNELLY | admitted May 22 1769 |
| 10 | Thos. BARCLAY | admitted May 22 1769 |
| 11 | John BARCLAY | admitted May 22 1769 |
| 12 | Wm. MCFADIN | admitted May 22 1769 |
| 13 | Thos. CONNELLY | admitted May 22 1769 |
| 14 | Patk. CORR | admitted May 22 1769 |
| 15 | John HANDCOCK | admitted May 22 1769 |
| 16 | Barny NEALE | admitted Nov 9 1770 |
| 17 | Henry GARLAND | admitted Nov 9 1770 |
| 18 | Jas. MCGUIRE | admitted Nov 9 1770 |
| 19 | Wm. MCCLEAN | admitted Nov 9 1770 |
| 20 | Barthw. GRIFFIN | admitted Nov 9 1770 |
| 21 | Wm. BAILLY | admitted Nov 9 1770 |
| 22 | Thos. BAILLY | admitted Nov 9 1770 |
| 23 | Edwd. MACKEL | admitted Nov 9 1770 |
| 24 | Wm. IRWIN | admitted Nov 9 1770 |
| 25 | Henry NEILL | admitted June 5 1775 |
| 26 | Jas. NEILL | admitted June 5 1775 |
| 27 | Chas. MANN | admitted June 5 1775 |
| 28 | Thos. STURGEON | admitted June 5 1775 |
| 29 | Jas. BLACK | admitted June 5 1775 |
| 30 | Edwd. MCGUIRE | admitted June 5 1775 |
| 31 | Jno. MCFADIN | admitted June 5 1775 |
| 32 | Edwd. IRWIN | admitted June 5 1775 |
| 33 | Gilbt. CONLAN | admitted June 5 1775 |
| 34 | Wm. HALL | admitted June 5 1775 |
| 35 | John MCMULLIN | admitted May 20 1776 |
| 36 | Thos. GREEN | admitted Dec 20 1776 |
| 37 | Jno. WALLACE | admitted Dec 6 1776 |
| 38 | Jas. DONLEY | admitted Dec 6 1776 |
| 39 | Jas. DEVELIN | admitted Dec 6 1776 |
| 40 | Jno. MCCAHELY | admitted Dec 6 1776 |
| 41 | Peter LOGAN | admitted Dec 6 1776 |
| 42 | Henry GRIMLEY | admitted Dec 6 1776 |
| 43 | Jno. VALELLY | admitted Dec 6 1776 |
| 44 | Roger MALONE | admitted Jany 23 1778 |
| 45 | Henry CARSON | admitted Jany 23 1778 |
| 46 | Henry NEILL | admitted Jany 23 1778 |
| 47 | Jno. NUNREY | admitted Jany 23 1778 |
| 48 | Jno. FARNAN | admitted April 24 1780 |
| 49 | Pat. MCGRATH | admitted April 24 1780 |
| 50 | Wm. ROBINSON | admitted April 24 1780 |
| 51 | Joseph KELLY | admitted April 24 1780 |
| 52 | Tho. MCCLOSKY | admitted 8 Jan 1781 |
| 53 | Ferdinand MADDEN | admitted May 8 1782 |
| 54 | Hugh HAGAN | admitted May 8 1782 |
| 55 | Thos. MORRIS | admitted May 8 1782 |
| 56 | George TRENAR | admitted Jany 23 1783 |
| 57 | Wm. HENDERSON | admitted Jany 23 1783 |
| 58 | Owen HUGHES | admitted Jany 23 1783 |
| 59 | Pat. CONNOR | admitted Jany 23 1783 |
| 60 | Jas. CAMPBELL | admitted Jany 23 1783 |
| 61 | Phelix HUGHES | admitted Apl 10 1783 |
| 62 | Peter QUIN | admitted Apl 10 1783 |
| 63 | Hugh DUFFY | admitted Apl 10 1783 |
| 64 | Peter NEALE | admitted Apl 10 1783 |
| 65 | Hugh MCKEAGHY | admitted Apl 10 1783 |
| 66 | Neil MCQUAID | admitted Apl 10 1783 |
| 67 | Jno. CAVENAGH | admitted June 26 1784 |
| 68 | Jno. SHORT | admitted Jany 6 1786 |
| 69 | Danl. FALLS | admitted Jany 6 1786 |
| 70 | Jas. MCKENNA | admitted March 8 1786 |
| 71 | Jno. MULLIN | admitted March 8 1786 |
| 72 | Patk. MALONE | admitted March 8 1786 |
| 73 | Neil O’NEILL | admitted March 8 1786 |
| 74 | Pat. MCSHERRY | admitted March 8 1786 |
| 75 | John HEADON | admitted March 8 1786 |
| 76 | Pat. LAUGHRAN | admitted March 8 1786 |
| 77 | Martin GARLAND | admitted Dec 7 1787 |
| 78 | Wingfield DELAVEL | admitted Dec 7 1787 |
| 79 | Owen GALDEN | admitted Dec 7 1787 |
| 80 | Allen DOYLE | admitted Dec 7 1787 |
| 81 | Arthur MALONE | admitted Dec 7 1787 |
| 82 | Nich. GILFOYLE | admitted Dec 7 1787 |
| 83 | Arthur MCCARTIN | admitted Dec 7 1787 |
| 84 | Jno. MCCAY | admitted May 30 1790 |
| 85 | Cancelled | admitted May 30 1790 |
| 86 | Pat. LAPPAN | admitted June 29 1790 |
| 87 | David WATERS | admitted June 29 1790 |
| 88 | Nich. GERNAN? | admitted June 29 1790 |
| 89 | Jno. MCCLEAN | admitted June 29 1790 |
| 90 | Edwd. LAMIE | admitted June 29 1790 |
| 91 | Frans. MULLAN | admitted June 29 1790 |
| 92 | Hugh MCDONELL | admitted June 29 1790 |
| 93 | Jas. MCCUSKER | admitted Decr 24 1790 |
| 94 | Wm. REED | admitted April 8 1792 |
| 95 | Owen HAGAN | admitted April 8 1792 |
| 96 | Jas. CLARK | admitted April 8 1792 |
| 97 | Jno. MCCOURD | admitted April 8 1792 |
| 98 | Bernd. MURPHY | admitted April 8 1792 |
| 99 | Jas. WOODS | admitted April 8 1792 |
| 100 | Heny. HUGHES | admitted April 8 1792 |
| 101 | Mich. DARBY | admitted April 8 1792 |
| 102 | Pat. MALONE | admitted April 8 1792 |
| 103 | Pat. VALLELY | admitted June 7 1792 |
| 104 | Jas. WATTERS | admitted Oct 4 1794 |
| 105 | Jno. MCCORMICK | admitted Oct 4 1794 |
| 106 | Owen CALLAGHAN | admitted Aug 20 1796 |
| 107 | John MCOWEN | admitted Aug 20 1796 |
| 108 | Pat. MCSHERRY | admitted Aug 20 1796 |
| 109 | Pat. HENEY | admitted Aug 20 1796 |
| 110 | Jno. HANDCOCK | admitted Aug 20 1796 |
| 111 | Alex. SAINTFORD | admitted Aug 20 1796 |
| 112 | Alex. GILDERNEW | admitted Nov 25 1797 |
| 113 | Wm. QUIN | admitted Nov 25 1797 |
| 114 | Francis MCILVENEY | admitted Nov 25 1797 |
| 115 | Thos GRANT | admitted Nov 25 1797 |
| 116 | Jas. ROBINSON | admitted Nov 25 1797 |
| 117 | Denis WALSH | admitted Nov 25 1797 |
| 118 | Richd. MCGINN | admitted Nov 25 1797 |
| 119 | Jno. CARROLL | admitted Nov 25 1797 |
| 120 | Toole MCKENNA | admitted Feb 16 1801 |
| 121 | Jas. MCKEOWN | admitted June 23 1801 |
| 122 | Will. YOUNG | admitted June 23 1801 |
| 123 | Pat. MCMANUS | admitted Dec 5 1801 |
| 124 | Jas. FOX | admitted Jan 13 1802 |
| 125 | Pat. MCVEY | admitted Feb 18 1802 |
| 126 | Pat HIGGINS | admitted Mar 5 1802 |
| 127 | Heny. MARA | admitted June 13 1804 |
| 128 | Owen QUINN | admitted Nov 24 1804 |
| 129 | Pat MANGIN | admitted Dec 24 1804 |