Members of Lodge No. 333 meeting at Caledon would have been drawn from the surrounding district. Meetings were generally held on the night of a full moon allowing for safe travel on horseback in an era of poor quality roads
***ORIGINAL SPELLING AND NUMBERING OF MEMBERSHIP HAS BEEN RETAINED***
| No. | Member | When Admitted | Made Master | Made Warden |
| 1 | William DONNELY | Sept 6 1759 | Sep 6 1759 | |
| 2 | Michl. LYONS | do. | Sept 6 1759 | |
| 3 | William MAXWELL | do. | do. | |
| 4 | Thos LEWIS | do. | June 24 1764 | |
| 5 | Robt GILLASPY [GILLESPIE] | do. (excluded) | ||
| 6 | Hugh PEPPER | do. (excluded) | ||
| 7 | John FILSTON | do. | ||
| 8 | James BRISBEN [BRISBANE] | do. (left the Kingdom) | ||
| 9 | Robt. MERCER | do. | ||
| 10 | Frans. CALLAGHAN | do. | ||
| 11 | Thos. DUNN | do. (left) | June 24 1764 | |
| 12 | Denis HUGHES | do. | ||
| 13 | James NORRIS | do. (left) | ||
| 14 | Patrick DRANE | do. (excluded) | ||
| 15 | Philip HUGHES | do. (left & C….?) | ||
| 16 | Roger NEAL | do. (dead) | ||
| 17 | Patrick HUGHES | Jul 2 1760 (left) | ||
| 18 | Stanley WHITE | do. | June 24 1764 | |
| 19 | Michl. MCNALLY | Sept 3 1760 (left & returned) | ||
| 20 | James BROWN | Dec 9 1760 (left the Kingdom) | ||
| 21 | John HARDING | June 24 1763 | ||
| 22 | Robt HENDERSON | Nov 26 1763 | ||
| 23 | Danl MACKEY | Nov 26 1763 | ||
| 24 | Mathw. BLACK | Do. | ||
| 25 | Hugh DALY | June 24 1765 | ||
| 26 | John STEVENSON | June 25 1771 | ||
| 27 | John MARSHALL | do. | ||
| 28 | Jas. HARCOURT | do. | ||
| 29 | John KEANE | do. | ||
| 30 | John DALY | do. | ||
| 31 | Mark REYNOLDS | do. | June 25 1771 | |
| 32 | Hen: CAMPBELL | do. | ||
| 33 | Fran: MARSHALL | do. | ||
| 34 | Tho. MCCAMMON | do. | ||
| 35 | Pat. QUINN | do.. | ||
| 36 | Robt HASTINGS | do. | ||
| 37 | Wm. MULLIGAN | do. | ||
| 38 | Hugh MCCAMMON | do. | ||
| 39 | John BELL | do. | ||
| 40 | Pat. CAMPBELL | do. | ||
| 41 | Wm. GEOUGH | June 16 1770 | ||
| 42 | Robt ROGERS | July 2 1770 | ||
| 43 | Robt COCHRAN | do. | ||
| 44 | Alex MCCLEAN | do. | ||
| 45 | Wm CRAWFORD | do. | ||
| 46 | John CHAPMAN | June 27 1771 | ||
| 47 | Joseph BURNS | do. | ||
| 48 | John MERCER | do. | ||
| 49 | Alex ANDERSON | May 22 1773 | ||
| 50 | John ANDERSON | do. | ||
| 51 | Geo. KERR | May 22 1773 | ||
| 52 | Jno. GORDON | do. | ||
| 53 | Jas. MOORE | do. | ||
| 54 | Wm. GRIFFITH | do. | ||
| 55 | Saml BELL | do. | ||
| 56 | Jas BELL | do. | ||
| 57 | Hugh MCCLEARY | Sept 28 1776 | ||
| 58 | Robt. WRIGHT | do. | ||
| 59 | Jno. GOE | do. | ||
| 60 | Hugh DONNELLY | do. | ||
| 61 | Henry MERCER | do. | ||
| 62 | James HUGHES | do. | ||
| 63 | Alex HENRY | do. | ||
| 64 | Wm SCROGGY | do. | ||
| 65 | Jas. MCDONALD | do. | ||
| 66 | Hugh O’NEIL | do. (cert June 1 1773) | ||
| 67 | Jno. ALLEN | do. | ||
| 68 | Jno HANNA | do. | ||
| 69 | Robt MERCER | do. | ||
| 70 | Jno HUTCHISON | do. | ||
| 71 | Robt HENDERSON | do. | ||
| 72 | James WOODS | Nov 28 1778 (cert June 1 1779) | ||
| 73 | Richd. STUTT | June 1 1779 (cert July 25 1781) | ||
| 74 | Pat MCKENNA | do. (cert. June 1 1779) | ||
| 75 | Robt. MCKENNA | March 13 1781 | ||
| 76 | Jno. LIVINGSTON | do. | ||
| 77 | Hugh MCNEILLY | March 12 1783 (cert March 12 1783) | ||
| 78 | Wm KERR | do. (cert march 22 1784) | ||
| 79 | Wm CROSS | Nov 30 1783 (cert Nov 10 1783) | ||
| 80 | Richd ROBINSON | Nov 30 1783 (cert 20 1783) | ||
| 81 | George LINN | Nov 30 1783 (cert May 5 1794) | ||
| 82 | Jas WALSH | March 22 1784 (cert May 8 1784) | ||
| 83 | Jas CAMPBELL | March 22 1784 | ||
| 84 | Alex LATIMER | March 27 1788 (cert March 27 1788) | ||
| 85 | Edmd WRIGHT | April 22 1789 (cert April 22 1789) | ||
| 86 | Wm. JOFFERS/ JEFFERS | Feb 6 1790 | ||
| 87 | Jas. LOUGHEAD | do. | ||
| 88 | Thos. WOGAN | do. | ||
| 89 | Robt. LANG | do. | ||
| 90 | Jas WOODS | Feb 6 1790 | ||
| 91 | Wm. FRAZER | do. | ||
| 92 | Chas NORRIS | do. (cert May 17 1794) | ||
| 93 | Thos. HARRINGTON | do. | ||
| 94 | Thos. LEE | do. | ||
| 95 | David HANCE | do. | ||
| 96 | Moses GORDON | do. | ||
| 97 | Moses MCGUFFIN | do. (cert July 28 1790) | ||
| 98 | Wm HARPER | do. |