Earliest registers destroyed in Dublin, 1922. No registers are available for viewing and researching at the Public Record Office of Northern Ireland (PRONI), Belfast. Surviving records remain at the church: Baptisms 1873-; Marriages 1845-; Burials 1879-; Vestry minutes 1911-.
NOTE: Only a partial listing.
| Surname | Transcription |
| McConnell | In everlasting memory of Charlotte Mary, died 19 December 1941 and her husband, William, died 10 December 1953 aLso their son, Norman William, died 21 November 1980 |
| McGlaughlin | Erected by Mary Ann in memory of her beloved husband, James McGlaughlin, late of Garvagh, who died on the 11 June 1862, aged 25 years other parts are badly deteriorated the above Mary Ann, died August 1926, aged 88 years |
| Brewster | Erected to the memory of his beloved wife, Mary Brewster, died 22 February 1878, aged 68 years by her attached husband, James Brewster and by Carolyn Oliver, Redmond MacAugland and Charlotte Smith in grateful remembrance of their faithful nurse. here also lieth her husband, James Brewster, who died 9 December 1891 |
| McDonald | In loving memory of June, a devoted wife, mother and grandmother, born 22 June 1944, died 29 January 1997 |
| Rankin | In loving memory of James Rankin, C. P. S, died 13 September 1942 |
| Bell | Elizabeth Bell, who departed this life (need better light to read) |
| Patton Clarke Campbell Wilson |
In loving memory of William and Mary Patton, Farrintemple and their children, Hugh and Georgina, Rebecca Clark, Margaret, Mary Campbell, Matilda Wilson |
| Little | In loving memory of Susan, the beloved wife of John J. Little, Garvagh, who departed this life, 2 December 1927 also the above named John J. Little, called to higher service, 21 October 1946 |
| Pollock | Erected by Pollock brothers, in memory of their beloved mother, Mary Anne, who died 21 May 1894, aged 60 years |
| Thompson | Treasured memories of my much loved and loving wife, Kathleen, called home on the 4 July 1986 |
| Thompson Gilmour |
Erected in the memory of Isabella Thompson, of Tamneymore, who departed this life, 18 December 1887, aged 88 years also, Isabelle Gilmour Thompson, granddaughter of above, who departed this life, 6 September 1918, in her 50th years Elizabeth, wife of Wm. Thompson, died 25 December 1924, aged 86 years Wm., husband of Elizabeth Thompson died 5 October 1927, in his 95th year also their son, William Thompson, died 17 March 1930 aged 57 years Sadie C. Thompson, wife of T.B. Thompson, died 25 August 1936 T.B. Thompson, husband of Sadie Thompson, died 3 January 1958, aged 83 years and their son, William (Billy) L. Thompson, died 10 November 1973 also his wife, Rebecca Gertrude (Ruby), died 15 August 1972, interred in First Garvagh Presbyterian Churchyard |
| Millar | Here lieth the body of William Millar, who departed this life, 12 March 1836, aged 26years David Millar, Garvagh, who departed this life 10 December 1838, aged 77 years his wife, Elizabeth Millar, in May 1839, aged 70 years and his grandson, John Millar on the 18 February 1859, aged 30 years |
| Wade | Small stone, no other information |
| Wade | William John, died 2 April 1996 and son, Robert, lost at sea, 9 May 1967, aged 18 years |
| Bell | In loving memory of Pearl, who died 23 August 1941, aged 21 years a also her father, John Bell, who died 20 October 1970, aged 91 years a and her mother, Sarah Bell, who died 3 December 1976, aged 86 years |
| Dillion | Treasured memories of Maurice, 11 February 1978 |
| Dale | In loving memory of John Dale, who died 1 April 1936 and his wife, Isabell Johnston, who died 7 January 1902 and their daughters Jane, who died 15 May 1906 Eliza, who died 19 January 1941 Erected by their daughter Carrie |
| Mullan | Erected by Alexander Mullan, in memory of his brother, William, who died 20 January 1912 and Martha, wife of William, who died 6 February 1904 and his father and mother, Alexander and Sarah, and his sister, Louise the above named Alexander, who died 12 July 1913 and his wife, Elizabeth, who died 18 November 1938 also their son, Alexander, who died 30 December 1983 |
| Bell | Erected by Thomas Bell in memory of his wife, Elizabth, who departed this life 10 December 1878, aged 79 years to her husband, Thomas of Mettican, who died 29 June 1886, aged 83 years |
| McAlister | Erected by Anthony McAlister, C.P. (needed better light to read) |
| Scholes | Erected by Jane Scholes, in memory of her dear husband, John. T. Scholes, manager, Ulster Bank, Ulster Bank, Garvagh, died 1 Octobe 1898, aged 62 years and his eldest son, William, died 8 January 1912, aged 29 years |
| Scholes | In loving memory of John S. T., son of John T. and Jane Scholes, died 5 February 1887, also Francis M. , died 8 September 1894, aged 14 years |
| Robertsons Cunningham |
Sacred to the memory of Robert Robertson, late of Garvagh, who died the 1 April 1834, aged 57 years Here are likewise interred the remains of his wife, Jane Robertson, alias Cunningham, who departed this life, 29 August 1848, aged 73 years also David Robertson, Ballynacally, who died 19 July 1882, aged 67 years and his beloved wife, Matilda Robertson, who died 26 September 1883, aged 58 years and his son, Robert John, who died 21 March 1882, aged 25 years |
| Robertson Conway Brooks |
In loving memory of Sadie Robertson, Ballymoney, died 11 May 1903, aged 1 year and 10 months also her father, David Robertson, died 9 July 1926 also her mother, Matilda, died 27 May 1938 and their daughter, Maud Conway, died 5 October 1950, aged 51 years Erected by Sadie Brooks, Philadelphia, for her niece |
| Paul Smith Ritchey |
In memory of James Ritchey Paul, late of Groghan, who died 9 January 1859, aged 2 years and 6 months Mary Ann Smith Ritchey, died 23 June 1918, aged 60 years |
| Ritchie | Erected to the memory of John Ritchie, Farrentemple, who died 16 December 1921 and his daughters Mary Ann, who died 30 May 1938 Margaret Jane, who died 20 November 1944 and his son, William James, who died 21 March 1949 |
| Craig | Treasured memories of Matilda, died 5 May 1975 her son, James, died 4 June 1999 |
| McCahon | In loving memory of my dear husband, Stewart McCahon, Gortfadd, who died 29 March 1953, aged 75 years |
| McDade | Charles McDade, who died 19 August 1867, aged 11 years |
| Macausland | Sacred to the memory of Caroline Macausland, who exchanged this life for immortality on the 24 October 1857 and her sister, Hanna Macausland, who died 27 August 1881, aged 84 years |
| Mascausland | Sacred to the memory of Mary Ann Mascausland, who exchanged this life for immortality on the 26 April 1861 also rest her sister, Letitia Mascausland, who died on the 17 October 1863 |
| Ross | Elizabeth Ross, who died 19 September 1875 (needed better light to read the stone) |
| Macloy Henderson |
In memory of Neally Macloy, late of Tirkeeran, and his wife, Jeannie Henderson |